Deductive Versus Inductive Reasoning

Kittenflies™ ExploreRhetoric for KidsDeductive vs. Inductive

Deductive Versus Inductive Reasoning

Two ways to reason: top-down and bottom-up.

Reasoning

Persuading with reasons

Reasoning can be an effective way to convince someone. You probably reason with others every day. For example, you may have to persuade your brother to share the last few sips of his strawberry milkshake. Two kinds of reasoning, deductive and inductive, illustrate why some methods of persuasion are more effective than others due to their basis in truth.

Deductive reasoning

Top-down logic

Deductive reasoning, also called top-down logic, starts off with a general statement, such as “All green plants need sunlight.” The next step is reducing the general to a particular example, like “This rosebush is a green plant.” Finally, you draw a conclusion: “Therefore, this rosebush needs sunlight.”

Deductive reasoning that is based on a general statement of fact is hard to argue with. When using this method, you begin with a factual statement that describes a class of things, such as animals. For example, you might say, “all animals need oxygen.” Because this is true of every animal, it is true of each animal as well. Therefore, you can truthfully conclude that a specific animal, like your pet gerbil, needs oxygen.

Spot the flaw

When the reasoning is faulty

However, when the reasoning is faulty, deduction is open to debate:

Try it
Valid arguments

If this premise is true…

When it’s not possible for the premise to be true and the conclusion to be false, you are looking at a valid argument.

  • All cats are animals. If this premise is true…
  • This tabby is a cat.
  • Therefore, this tabby is an animal.  … it is impossible for this conclusion to be false. Thus, we have a valid argument.
Sound arguments

Start with a true premise

And when you have a true premise, you have the foundation for a sound argument.

  • All cats are females. This premise is not true, thus we don’t have a sound argument.
  • This tabby is a cat.
  • Therefore, this tabby is a female.
  • All cats are animals. This premise is true, so we are able to build a valid argument to prove a conclusion.
  • This tabby is a cat.
  • Therefore, this tabby is an animal.

When you use deduction to come up with a valid and sound logical argument, you are offering up a deductive demonstration.

Inductive reasoning

Bottom-up logic

Inductive reasoning, or bottom-up logic, is the reverse of deductive reasoning. This method begins with specific pieces of information or observations, and then it concludes with a generalization that may or may not be factual:

  • My bicycle has a flat tire.
  • My bicycle is silver.
  • Therefore, all silver bicycles have flat tires.

If you think this line of reasoning seems slightly off, give yourself a pat on the back. Inductive reasoning is rarely as sound as deductive reasoning because it leaps from limited experience to sweeping generalities:

  • Every fire hydrant in my neighborhood is red.
  • Every fire hydrant in my best friend’s neighborhood is red.
  • Therefore, every fire hydrant in town is red.
Inductive reasoning

Strong or weak?

The premises of inductive arguments do not prove their conclusions, but rather they support them. This is because the premises here are inferences. We are not certain if the inference is true or not. We want to make inferences that are more probable, as opposed to “risky” inferences. The strength of the argument depends on how strong the inference is. How probable does this inference need to be in order for us to accept the conclusion? The support for these inductive arguments lies in this area of “how probable” are these inferences. The less support provided, the weaker the argument. The more support provided, the stronger the argument. So the goal with inductive arguments is to be STRONG.

Deductive arguments have the goal of being VALID. If we have legitimate premises and then we draw the conclusion, we will know with certainty what is going on.

To recap, good logical arguments can come in two varieties: deductive demonstrations and inductive supporting arguments.

A historical example

Lincoln finds a faulty premise

In the Lincoln-Douglas debates, Lincoln found a fault in one of the premises that builds the argument below. Can you find the faulty premise below?

Try it
Today’s activities

Sound deductions?

1. Look at the examples below and decide whether they are sound deductions.

Try it
Today’s activities

Finish the inductions

2. Create a logical conclusion based on the following examples of inductive reasoning. Then decide whether the reasoning is sound.

Try it

You’re a logical thinker!

Deductive demonstrations and inductive supporting arguments: now you know both.

Read the original blog post →